From Shubhi K | Product & Market Analysis
Gallup Span of Control: The Average Hit 12.1, the Median Stayed at 6
On this page
The average US manager had 12.1 direct reports in 2025, up from 10.9 in 2024, according to Gallup. The typical manager did not change. Gallup puts the median span of control at about six, and says the rise came largely from teams of 25 or more. For org design, that means the headline describes a minority of very wide teams, not your median manager.
Key takeaways
- The 12.1 average is pulled up by a long tail. Gallup reports 66% of US managers lead fewer than 10 people and 13% lead 25 or more, with a median span of about six direct reports.
- About 45% of all direct reports sit with the widest 13% of managers. That is our reconstruction from Gallup's published bands using bucket midpoints, and it holds between roughly 39% and 48% under other reasonable assumptions.
- The 1.2-point rise clears Gallup's sampling error, but only just. Using the widest margin Gallup states for its yearly means, the change could plausibly be as small as about 0.1 or as large as about 2.3.
- Gallup's data contains no measure of AI use. Its span article mentions AI once, as a source of uncertainty, so wider spans cannot yet be read as proof that AI lets managers lead more people.
Reader: this post is written for ops and delivery leads redesigning team structures, because they are the people most likely to turn a benchmark into a span target this quarter.
The short answer. Gallup's average US span of control rose from 10.9 to 12.1 direct reports between 2024 and 2025. The median stayed near six. The increase came mainly from a 2-point rise in managers leading 25 or more people. Flatter averages are not evidence that typical managers now lead more people, or that AI caused it.
What Gallup's span of control data actually measured in 2025
The source is a Gallup article by Jim Harter, published 13 January 2026, titled Span of Control: What's the Optimal Team Size for Managers? Its headline finding is the move from 10.9 to 12.1 direct reports. Gallup also says team size has risen nearly 50% since it first measured in 2013.
The question Gallup asked managers was simple: how many people report directly to you? The answer is self-reported. It counts direct reports, not total headcount under a leader, so a director with five managers below them answers five.
That definition matters more than it looks. A survey of managers and leaders mixes frontline supervisors in services with engineering leads and executives. A shift-floor supervisor with 30 people and a product lead with 6 both count as one manager each.
Two samples, two definitions
The article blends several data sets, and they should not be confused. The span trend comes from yearly samples of US managers: 4,355 in 2024 and 8,795 in 2025. The engagement analysis draws on a 2022 to 2024 panel of 16,442 managers and a separate panel of 44,025 adults.
The outcome research is a third thing entirely. Gallup pooled 92,252 teams covering 897,971 employees across 104 organisations in 46 countries. That meta-analysis is global and organisational. The 12.1 figure is a weighted US national sample. Quoting one as support for the other is the most common mistake in coverage of this study.
Why the span of control average moved and the median did not
An average and a median answer different questions. The average spreads every direct report evenly across every manager. The median is the manager in the middle of the line, with half leading fewer people and half leading more.
When a distribution has a long right tail, those two numbers separate. Gallup's span data has exactly that shape. Most managers lead small teams, and a minority lead very large ones. Here the average is roughly double the median, which is the signature of a skewed distribution.
The arithmetic of a skewed distribution
Gallup gives four facts about the 2025 shape. 37% of managers lead fewer than 5 people, 66% lead fewer than 10, 22% lead 10 to 24, and 13% lead 25 or more. Subtracting gives 29% in the 5 to 9 band. The four bands sum to 101%, a rounding artefact in the source.
With 66% of managers below 10, the median has to fall below 10 as well. Gallup places it at about six. An average of 12.1 sitting above two-thirds of all managers tells you the tail is doing the work.
I would not set a span target from the 12.1 figure. It is a correct number that answers the wrong question for anyone designing a team. You staff the manager in front of you, and that manager looks far more like six than twelve.
Where the direct reports actually sit
Gallup publishes shares of managers. It does not publish shares of employees by their manager's span. That second view is the one an operator needs, so we reconstructed it.
The method is plain. We assigned each closed band its midpoint: 2.5 reports for fewer than 5, 7 for 5 to 9, and 17 for 10 to 24. We multiplied each by its share of managers. Whatever is left of the 12.1 average must come from the 25-plus band.
| Span band | Share of managers (Gallup) | Assumed average span | Contribution to 12.1 average | Share of all direct reports |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fewer than 5 | 37% | 2.5 (midpoint) | 0.93 | About 8% |
| 5 to 9 | 29% (derived) | 7 (midpoint) | 2.03 | About 17% |
| 10 to 24 | 22% | 17 (midpoint) | 3.74 | About 31% |
| 25 or more | 13% | About 42 (solved) | 5.41 | About 45% |
Working: 0.37 x 2.5 + 0.29 x 7 + 0.22 x 17 = 6.70. Then 12.1 minus 6.70 = 5.41, and 5.41 divided by 0.13 = about 42 reports per manager in the top band. Shares of direct reports are each contribution divided by 12.1. Midpoints are our assumption, not Gallup's.
Two results fall out. The two-thirds of managers leading fewer than 10 people hold only about a quarter of all direct-report relationships. The 13% leading 25 or more hold close to half of them, at an implied average of about 42 people each.
That second figure is the one to remember. A typical employee in this data set is quite likely to report to someone with a very wide span. A typical manager is not. Both statements are true at the same time, and confusing them is how a benchmark turns into a bad target.
What a 2-point shift can do to an average
Gallup says the 2025 rise was largely influenced by a 2-point increase in teams of 25 or more. Test that against the reconstruction. Move 2% of managers from a 7-person team to a 42-person team, and the average rises by 0.02 x 35, or 0.7 direct reports.
That accounts for roughly 58% of the 1.2-point rise, which fits the word "largely". The rest could come from large teams getting larger, or from small shifts elsewhere. Either way, a change touching 2 managers in 100 moved the national headline by more than half a person per manager.
This is what averages do with tails. The same mechanism is why a single reorg at a large employer, of the kind tracked in the ledger of Amazon's manager ratio and delayering moves, can matter more to aggregate statistics than to the experience of a typical team.
Is the rise in Gallup manager direct reports statistically real?
Gallup states that the 95% margin of sampling error for its yearly mean estimates ranged from plus or minus 0.48 to plus or minus 0.78. It does not say which year carries which margin. So the honest move is to test the change at both ends.
For two independent samples, the margin on a difference is roughly the square root of the sum of the squared margins. At the tightest stated margin, that is about 0.68. At the widest, about 1.10. The observed change of 1.2 clears both, so the rise is very unlikely to be pure sampling noise.
Overlapping bars are not the test
Plot each year with its own band and the two ranges overlap between about 11.3 and 11.7. Readers often take overlap to mean "no real change". That rule is wrong, because the uncertainty on a difference is smaller than the sum of the two individual margins.
The fair summary is narrower than the headline. The average probably rose. Under the widest margin, the true change could be anywhere from about 0.1 to about 2.3 direct reports. A post claiming managers took on "1.2 more people" is quoting the point estimate as if it were exact. For more on how survey margins get flattened in AI coverage, see the breakdown of methodology gaps in AI ROI surveys.
Why flat organization data is not yet AI evidence
The tempting story writes itself. Companies adopt AI, managers get leverage, organisations remove layers, spans widen. Gallup's 2025 number looks like confirmation. It is not, and the article itself says so by omission.
What Gallup says about AI, in full
The span article mentions AI in one sentence. Gallup writes that uncertainty about the future effects of AI on team size and employee management may add extra pressure. That is the entire AI content. There is no question on AI use, no split by AI exposure, and no comparison of managers who use AI tools against those who do not.
The same article names other forces. It refers to a "Great Flattening", to large technology companies eliminating middle-management layers, and to Amazon discussing fewer management roles to lower costs. Those are cost decisions. A span can widen because a company removed managers to save money, with no change at all in what each remaining manager can handle.
My read is that 2025's wider average is better explained as a cost-and-layoff story concentrated in very large teams. That pattern fits the corrections described in the analysis of AI layoffs as an overhiring correction more closely than it fits a productivity story.
What would count as evidence is not hard to describe. You would want spans measured alongside AI use, at the same managers, over time, with team outcomes held up. If AI-using managers widened spans while engagement and output stayed level, that would be a finding. Nothing in the 2025 release does that, and I would treat any vendor deck citing 12.1 as AI proof as a reason to ask harder questions.
What wide spans cost the managers holding them
Gallup's own conclusion is that manager talent trumps span of control. Highly engaged teams of 12 or more can thrive under a strong manager. That is a real finding, and it is conditional. The same research shows weaker managers losing engagement as team size and workload rise.
The wider context is not encouraging. In its April 2026 global workplace release, Gallup reported that manager engagement fell 5 points, from 27% to 22%, in 2025. Gallup says lower manager engagement accounts for much of the recent global decline. It also suggests, cautiously, that flattening may be a factor, based on South Asia, where manager numbers fell.
The player-coach problem
Span is not the only load. Gallup reports that 97% of managers carry some individual contributor work, at a median of 40% of their time. A manager with 12 reports and a full personal workload is running two jobs.
The worst combination in Gallup's analysis is a very large team plus individual contributor work above 40%. High-talent managers in that position held up. Medium- and low-talent managers did not. If your plan widens spans without removing personal deliverables, you are betting on every manager being in the top talent band.
Remote spans behave differently
Gallup found the effect of team size on manager engagement is strongest for managers working remotely or hybrid. For on-site managers, rising team size had minimal impact. That fits common sense. A floor supervisor can see 25 people at once. A remote lead has to book 25 one-to-ones.
Feedback is where this bites. Gallup reports that employees who strongly agree they got meaningful feedback in the past week are engaged at about seven in 10, against about one in four otherwise. Every added report is another weekly conversation. That arithmetic belongs in the plan, and in how review criteria are being rewritten around AI work.
Where this reading of the span data is weakest
This post argues the headline overstates what happened to typical managers. There are three places where that argument is softer than it reads.
Bucket midpoints are an assumption
The 45% figure depends on our midpoints. If teams in the 10 to 24 band average nearer 20 than 17, the top band's share falls toward 39%. If they average nearer 15, it rises toward 48%. The direction of the finding survives every reasonable choice. The exact number does not, and it should be quoted as a reconstruction, never as a Gallup statistic.
The median is also less precise than it looks. Gallup gives it as "about five to six" in one place and as six in two others. It does not publish a 2024 median for comparison, so "the median did not move" rests on Gallup's description rather than a pair of published values.
Second, wide spans are not always a failure. Gallup's meta-analysis found that in services, transportation and healthcare, highly engaged large teams were more productive. Some work genuinely suits 25 people under one supervisor. A careful reader should not swing from "12.1 is the new normal" to "anything over 10 is broken".
Third, the AI case is unproven, not disproven. A small group of managers using AI to run very large teams would show up exactly as Gallup describes: a fatter tail and a flat median. The data cannot rule that out. It simply cannot confirm it. If you believe AI is widening spans, the burden is to show it with data that measures AI use.
Org design rules that survive Gallup's span of control data
The useful output of all this is not a number. It is a set of rules that hold whichever way the AI question resolves. The table contrasts the weak reading of the data with the one I would build on.
| Claim you will hear | What the data supports | What to do instead |
|---|---|---|
| Managers now lead 12 people on average, so set 12 as the target | The median manager leads about 6. The 12.1 figure is pulled up by a 13% tail. | Benchmark against medians and the full distribution, by work type. |
| AI is letting managers handle bigger teams | No AI measure exists in the span data. Gallup mentions AI once, as uncertainty. | Measure AI use and span at the same managers before claiming a link. |
| Spans rose 1.2, an exact and settled change | The change clears sampling error, with a plausible range of roughly 0.1 to 2.3. | Quote the direction with confidence and the size with a range. |
| Bigger teams always hurt engagement | Strong managers sustain large teams. On-site large teams are less affected. | Widen spans only where manager talent and on-site work support it. |
| Flatter is cheaper, so flatter is better | Manager engagement fell to 22% globally in 2025 as flattening continued. | Cost the lost coaching hours before banking the saved salary. |
Two of these rules matter most. First, set spans by the kind of work, not by a national figure. Second, every time you add a direct report, remove something else from that manager's personal workload. Without the second rule, a wider span is just a heavier one. The broader redesign question, of what middle managers should be doing at all, is taken up in the piece on middle management after agents.
It also helps to be honest about what flatter structures save. At a 600-person organisation, moving from an average span of 10.9 to 12.1 cuts the manager count from about 55 to about 50. That is five salaries. Whether it pays depends on what those 50 managers stop doing, which no span benchmark measures. Gallup's data on time is covered from another angle in the analysis of reported AI time savings against hours worked.
Frequently asked questions
What is the average span of control for managers in 2025?
Gallup reports the average US manager had 12.1 direct reports in 2025, up from 10.9 in 2024. The median was about six. The average is pulled up by the 13% of managers leading 25 or more people, so it describes very few actual managers. For team design, the median and the full distribution are more useful than the average.
How many direct reports should a manager have according to Gallup?
Gallup does not prescribe one number. Its January 2026 analysis concludes that manager talent matters more than team size, and that highly engaged teams of 12 or more can thrive under strong managers. It advises weighing the type of work, collaboration needs, individual contributor load and remote or on-site setting. Large teams suffered most under weaker, remote managers with heavy personal workloads.
Why did the average number of direct reports increase in 2025?
Gallup attributes the rise mainly to a two-percentage-point increase in teams of 25 or more. Our arithmetic suggests that shift alone could account for about 0.7 of the 1.2-point increase. The article also mentions middle-management cuts at large companies. It does not measure the causes directly, and it contains no data on AI use.
Is AI causing flatter organizations?
The span data cannot say. Gallup's article mentions AI once, as a source of uncertainty, and its survey does not record whether managers use AI tools. Wider average spans fit cost cutting and delayering equally well. Proving an AI effect would require measuring AI use and span at the same managers over time, alongside team outcomes.
What is the difference between mean and median span of control?
The mean divides all direct reports by all managers. The median is the middle manager when every manager is ranked by team size. In Gallup's 2025 data, the mean is 12.1 and the median about six, because most managers lead small teams while a minority lead very large ones. A gap that size signals a heavily skewed distribution.
Is the increase in manager span of control statistically significant?
Probably, but narrowly. Gallup states yearly margins of error between 0.48 and 0.78. Combining two independent samples at the widest margin gives a margin on the change of about 1.1, just under the observed 1.2. The true change could plausibly be as small as 0.1 or as large as 2.3 direct reports.
Where to start this week
Pull your own span distribution before you read another benchmark. Export manager IDs and direct-report counts from your HR system, and compute the median, the 25-plus share and the share of employees in each band. If your average sits well above your median, find the handful of very wide teams and decide whether each one is a design choice or an accident.
Then pick one wide team and audit the manager's week. Count the hours spent on personal deliverables and on one-to-ones. If personal work is above 40% of the week, cut that before you add a single report anywhere else.
References
- Gallup, Jim Harter, Span of Control: What's the Optimal Team Size for Managers?, 13 January 2026. Used for averages, median, distribution, samples, margins of error, meta-analysis and manager workload findings.
- Gallup, Jim Harter and Ryan Pendell, Global Employee Engagement Continues Decline, 7 April 2026. Used for manager engagement falling from 27% to 22% in 2025 and the flattening comment.
- Gallup, State of the Global Workplace, 2026 edition. Used for the 2022 to 2025 manager engagement trend and the global sample description.
- Zan Digital calculations: direct-report shares by band, implied 25-plus average, the 0.7 contribution of the 2-point shift and margins on the year-on-year change. Working shown in the body.
Weakest point in the source base: every span figure comes from one Gallup article, self-reported by managers, with no published 2024 median and no AI variable. The direct-report shares are our reconstruction from banded data. Figures last verified 10 November 2026.
Related reading